
Entry No. 31 — the El Paso & Fort Bliss file — filed under: miscellanea
Double Eagle Restaurant
An 1849 historic adobe hacienda famously haunted by teenage lovers Armando and Inez, who were killed in the Carlotta Room where chandeliers sway and phantom footsteps are heard.
→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in El Paso & Fort Bliss — never the same twice
The story
The sprawling adobe at the edge of the historic Mesilla Plaza was built around 1849 for the Maes family, wealthy merchants who fled south after the Mexican-American War shifted the border beneath their feet. Over the next century the house lived a fragmented life—decaying into a cotton warehouse and a clutch of forgotten storefronts—before oil tycoon Robert O. Anderson bought the shell in 1972. Anderson hired curator John Meigs to pack the 19th-century adobe with an astonishing hoard of European opulence: seven-foot French Baccarat crystal chandeliers, an 18- and 24-karat gold-leaf ceiling, Victorian child mourning portraits, and a 30-foot carved walnut and oak bar salvaged from a Prohibition-era speakeasy at Chicago's Drake Hotel.
The antiques are museum-grade, but the building’s real fixation is a blood feud from the 1850s. According to Mesilla lore, the matriarch Señora Carlota Maes had grand dynastic ambitions for her teenage son, Armando. Instead, Armando fell in love with Inez, a teenage servant girl in the household. When Carlota walked into her bedroom and caught the two teenagers embracing, she flew into a frenzy with a pair of sewing shears. Inez took the blades first; Armando dove in to shield her and was mortally stabbed. Carlota reportedly died broken-minded years later, but neither teenager ever cleared out of the bedroom, known today as the Carlotta Salon.
Staff, sheriff's deputies responding to midnight burglar alarms, and diners over the decades have reported the usual poltergeist repertoire: kitchen cutlery hurled across tile floors, wine glasses sliding across tables, and chandeliers swaying in sealed rooms. But the restaurant’s most famous artifact sits in the Carlotta Salon: a pair of plush velvet armchairs that sit permanently empty, yet show distinct, body-shaped indentations worn into the cushions. Waiters won't seat you in them—not out of museum etiquette, but because messing with the lovers' furniture tends to summon sudden icy drafts and uninvited attention.
What it's like
Entering off the historic Mesilla plaza feels like stepping out of the Chihuahuan desert directly into a gothic Gilded Age relic. The property actually functions in two gears: the formal Double Eagle dining rooms under crystal chandeliers and gold-leaf ceilings, and the sunnier, casual Peppers patio housed in the glass-topped interior courtyard. Double Eagle operates its own humidity- and temperature-controlled aging room for beef, but you don't need a full-blown prime-rib dinner to see the place; you can just pull up to the Chicago speakeasy bar for an Imperial margarita and posole. Weekend dinner services get packed and noisy, so visit on a quiet weekday afternoon if you actually want to duck into the Carlotta Salon and inspect the ghosts' chairs without someone asking you to move.
The move: Enter off the Mesilla plaza and dine beneath seven-foot Baccarat chandeliers and a gold-leaf ceiling, then lean on the 30-foot carved bar from Chicago's Drake Hotel and listen for phantom footsteps.
- 📍 Mesilla, New Mexico
- 💸 $$
- ⚡ Up for anything
- 🌗 Indoors
Where: 1948 Calle de Santiago (On the Plaza), Mesilla, NM 88046
Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.
Pair it with
- Recycled Roadrunner Sculpture — Only four miles up Interstate 10, this colossal roadside bird welded from scrap metal and discarded crutches makes a wildly unpretentious outdoor prelude before dinner beneath 24-karat gold leaf.
- Rosa’s Cantina — Trade Double Eagle's Baccarat chandeliers and ghost folklore for the gritty Doniphan watering hole forever immortalized in Marty Robbins' border ballad.
- National Border Patrol Museum — Spend the afternoon inspecting smuggler evasion shoes and vintage autogyros on Transmountain Pass before crossing the state line into Mesilla for an evening in a 19th-century murder room.
More weird in El Paso & Fort Bliss
Good to know
Can I sit in the ghost chairs in the Carlotta Salon?
No. The staff deliberately keeps them cordoned off from seating—both to preserve the historic upholstery and because disturbing the pair's perceived resting place is local taboo.
What is the difference between Double Eagle and Peppers?
They share the same building and kitchen. Double Eagle is the formal steakhouse with dry-aged beef, tableside service, and historic salons, while Peppers Cafe is a casual, plant-filled indoor courtyard serving green chile cheeseburgers, tacos, and New Mexican comfort fare.
Where did the giant wooden bar come from?
The 30-foot carved oak and walnut backbar was originally built for a Prohibition-era speakeasy operating inside Chicago's Drake Hotel, before being salvaged and transported to Mesilla during the 1970s restoration.
Is Billy the Kid connected to this building?
Nearby, yes, but specifically here: the restaurant's Billy the Kid Patio incorporates a carved newel post said to feature the outlaw's handiwork, while the building across the plaza was the actual courthouse where he was tried and sentenced to hang in 1881.
Plan a visit & invite your people →
Further reading: Facebook · Official site · kfoxtv.com · lascruces.com · lcsun-news.com
last checked: 2026-11-17

