
Entry No. 40 — the Fayetteville & Fort Liberty file — filed under: miscellanea
Garnet Skull
A spiritual shop listed among Fayetteville’s unique stores.
→ Three at a time, never the same twice — explore weird Fayetteville & Fort Liberty
The story
When co-owners Nik and Cheyenne Badolato outgrew their original storefront up the block at 220 Hay Street, they didn't leave downtown Fayetteville. In early 2024, they relocated to 120 Hay Street for one very practical reason: the ceilings were tall enough to properly accommodate their taxidermy mounts. In a city shaped heavily by Fort Liberty and strip-mall predictability, Garnet Skull carved out an unapologetic pocket of the arcane.
The shop functions as a hybrid between a 19th-century cabinet of curiosities and a functional esoteric apothecary. Rather than plastic Halloween kit, the inventory focuses on ethically sourced osteology, preserved skulls, raw mineral specimens, dried ritual herbs, and specialty loose-leaf teas. It has evolved into a quiet nerve center for downtown's offbeat crowd, regularly serving as the muster point for evening ghost walks and hosting Victorian oddities pop-ups during historic district street festivals.
What it's like
Stepping off Hay Street puts you into a moody, herb-scented space where preserved mounts watch over glass display cases lined with crystals, bones, and jars of loose botanical blends. Because the shop falls within downtown Fayetteville's designated Social District, you're permitted to carry an approved alcoholic beverage right through the front door while you browse. The staff let you explore without hovering, but they know the anatomical provenance of their taxidermy if you ask. Give fragile specimen glass a wide berth, and expect sidewalk crowds outside if your visit coincides with the weekend ghost tour departures.
The move: Browse the glass cases under the stare of taxidermy mounts, then each pick a favorite curiosity from the preserved skulls, raw minerals, and jars of loose botanicals.
- 📍 Fayetteville
- 💸 $$
- ⚡ Up for anything
- 🌗 Indoors
Where: 120 Hay Street, Fayetteville, NC 28301
Hours: Added 2026-11-18 — confirm current hours before you go.
Pair it with
- Winterbloom Tea — Just steps away on Hay Street, this spot mirrors Garnet Skull's herbal leanings by pouring loose-leaf teas by day and botanical elixirs by night.
- Bound & Vine — A block away, this hybrid independent bookstore and wine bar lets you pivot seamlessly from skull collecting to browsing paperbacks with a glass in hand.
- Circa 1800 — Round the corner toward Market Square to chase an afternoon of bone shopping with local farm-to-table cooking and North Carolina moonshine.
- Awesome Tattoos — Located nearby on Market Square, it makes a logical next stop if the shop's dark illustrative art leaves you itching for fresh ink.
More weird in Fayetteville & Fort Liberty
Good to know
What kind of items does Garnet Skull stock?
The shop focuses on ethically sourced taxidermy, animal skulls, bone specimens, raw crystals, loose-leaf teas, ritual herbs, and artwork by local North Carolina makers.
Can I bring a drink inside from nearby bars?
Yes. Garnet Skull is an official participant in the downtown Fayetteville Social District, allowing customers to bring approved open-container drinks inside while shopping during district hours.
Who owns and operates the shop?
The shop was founded and is operated by husband-and-wife duo Nik and Cheyenne Badolato, who moved the store down Hay Street in March 2024 to secure a larger historic space.
Do ghost tours meet here?
Yes. The storefront frequently serves as the downtown meeting and departure point for guided Fayetteville Ghost Walks.
Plan a visit & invite your people →
Further reading: Yelp · wral.com · fayettevillenc.net · bizfayetteville.com · Official site
last checked: 2026-11-18


