Historic ThistleDhu Mansion — Hidden Bars & Speakeasies in Fayetteville & Fort Liberty

Entry No. 36 — the Fayetteville & Fort Liberty file — filed under: miscellanea

Historic ThistleDhu Mansion

A seven-bedroom historic vacation rental with its own speakeasy, about a ten-minute walk from the village.

→ Three more hidden bars & speakeasies in Fayetteville & Fort Liberty — never the same twice

The story

In 1919, steamship magnate James Barber surveyed his newly completed 10,000-square-foot estate in Olde Town Pinehurst, reportedly announced to his wife that "this'll do," and had the phonetic pun carved in Scottish script as Thistle Dhu. Barber then contracted Edward H. Wiswell to build an 18-hole putting course across the garden, complete with geometric obstacles, brick borders, and hard-packed sand greens. Popular Science covered the setup that same year, inadvertently crowning Barber's private lawn as the birthplace of modern American miniature golf—a lineage Pinehurst Resort later honored when naming its own sprawling putting course.

The mansion took an even stranger turn mid-century. Following Barber's death, the estate was deeded to the Catholic Church and used as a retreat convent known to locals as "The Nunnery." That pious chapter left behind one of the oddest basement pairings in Moore County: an authentic, salvaged confessional booth sitting steps from the house's Roaring Twenties speakeasy bar. After later sitting abandoned for roughly two decades, the estate was rescued and renovated into a maximalist haven, preserving original heart-pine floors and antique moldings alongside psychedelic ceilings, modern art, and hidden entertaining vaults.

What it's like

Thistle Dhu operates strictly as a whole-house private luxury vacation rental, meaning you cannot stroll in off the street for a cocktail—you either rent the seven-bedroom property with a crew or get invited by someone who did. If you hold the keys, the focal point of the night is downstairs in the recreation lounge, where the hidden speakeasy bar and preserved confessional booth anchor the space. When you wander out to the front driveway in daylight, keep your eyes on the lawn to spot the surviving concrete edge of Barber's original 1919 putting track.

The move: Get a crew together to rent the seven-bedroom mansion, then slip downstairs together to see the hidden speakeasy bar and trade mock confessions by the old confessional booth.

Where: 12 E Barrett Rd, Pinehurst, NC 28374, USA

Hours: Added 2026-11-18 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Agora Bakery and Cafe — A three-minute cart ride into the village puts you in front of morning coffee served inside an old bank where the massive original vault door still looms.
  • Railway Express Speakeasy Train — Less than a mile away, you can continue the Prohibition-era drinking theme by boarding restored vintage train cars hidden on the Aberdeen Carolina & Western line.
  • Pinehurst Harness Track — Just a mile down the road, this 1915 clay-sand oval offers another slice of early 20th-century Pinehurst sporting history as standardbred horses run morning training laps.

More weird in Fayetteville & Fort Liberty

Good to know

Can I visit the speakeasy without booking the mansion?

No. Thistle Dhu is a private residence and vacation rental, not a commercial bar or public museum. The basement speakeasy, cinema, and grounds are accessible only to registered overnight guests.

Did miniature golf really start on this property?

Yes. Built in 1919 by James Barber and designed by Edward H. Wiswell, Thistle Dhu's yard was widely recognized in contemporary press as the first purposeful 18-hole miniature golf layout in the United States. Remnants of the original layout are still embedded in the lawn near the driveway.

Why is there a confessional booth in the basement?

After James Barber passed away, the property was gifted to the Catholic Church and served for years as a religious retreat and convent known locally as The Nunnery, leaving the confessional behind as a permanent architectural artifact.

How many people does the rental accommodate?

The estate spans over 10,400 square feet across 1.19 acres, featuring seven guest suites and ten bathrooms configured to sleep up to 14 guests.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: airbnb.com · files.nc.gov · ncpedia.org · pinestrawmag.com · realtor.com

last checked: 2026-11-18