Yours Truly — Hidden Bars & Speakeasies in Honolulu & Oahu
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 34 — the Honolulu & Oahu file — filed under: miscellanea

Yours Truly

An outdoor staircase leads beneath the AC Hotel to a front bar with a reservation-only tiki speakeasy in back. The rear room takes after a satellite post office, with vintage postcards and a mailbox wall where you submit your order and receive your cocktail.

→ Three more hidden bars & speakeasies in Honolulu & Oahu — never the same twice

The story

Skip the AC Hotel lobby entirely; your route takes you down a concrete exterior staircase dropping straight off Bishop Street into the subterranean dark. In the late 1890s, shortly after the annexation of Hawaiʻi, the U.S. Postal Service handed down a cease-and-desist to a printer who was churning out unauthorized photographs and postcards of "exotic Hawaiʻi" from a curio shop hidden beneath the downtown street. The printer ignored the federal order and kept his illegal subterranean press running. Yours Truly takes over that exact subterranean footprint, designed as a loving thumb in the eye of the postal authorities.

At first glance, the front room looks like a tidy, polished hotel lounge draped in Prohibition-era brass and velvet—enough to convince casual drop-ins that they have arrived at the destination. But check in with a reservation, and the host hands you a small brass key and a password. Push against what appears to be a solid bank of antique brass post office boxes, and the wall swings away to reveal an intentionally clashing backroom: thatched bamboo ceilings, hanging lanterns, and tables decoupaged with reproductions of the early-1900s postcards printed on the property.

The speakeasy leans all the way into postal mechanics for its service. You do not flag down a bartender. Instead, you write your drink order onto a souvenir postcard, match your brass key to your table's dedicated mailbox door on the back wall, and slot the card inside. Behind the wall, hidden bartenders mix classic and house-invented tiki drinks—Navy Grogs, Saturns, and fiery rum concoctions—and slide them into the mailbox compartment for you to retrieve.

What it's like

Look for the outdoor stairs immediately to the left of the AC Hotel's main entrance on Bishop Street rather than stepping inside the lobby. The front lounge accommodates walk-ins for classic cocktails, but crossing through the postbox wall into the tiki room requires an advance reservation. Time slots in the back speakeasy are strictly managed, so don't spend too long admiring the decoupage before dropping your postcard into the slot. For the calmest experience with time to actually study the vintage mail on the tables, book on a Wednesday or Thursday night rather than the packed weekend shifts.

The move: Book the back room, take the outdoor stairs off Bishop Street, and slip your order into the mailbox wall where your tiki cocktails come back like mail.

Where: AC Hotel by Marriott Honolulu, 1111 Bishop St, Honolulu, HI 96813 (Yours Truly located within the hotel)

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

⚠ Seasonal or scheduled — always check before you go.

Pair it with

  • Skull & Crown Trading Co. — A three-block walk into Chinatown pairs Yours Truly's playful postal-box speakeasy with Hollywood-effects horror tiki and real bone garnishes.
  • Hound & Quail — Comb through Chinatown's premier stash of taxidermy, vintage cameras, and oddities before descending underground for cocktails behind a wall of post office boxes.
  • Skull-Face Books & Vinyl — Dig through vintage horror paperbacks and offbeat records on Bethel Street just a block away before your reservation beneath Bishop Street.

More weird in Honolulu & Oahu

Good to know

Do I need a reservation to get into the back speakeasy?

Yes. While the front bar accepts walk-ins, the hidden room behind the mailbox wall is strictly reservation-only and should be booked online in advance.

How does the mailbox ordering system actually work?

Your party is given a brass key tied to a specific numbered post office box. You write your order on a provided postcard, unlock your table's mailbox, and slip the card inside; the bar crew behind the wall fills the order and slides the drinks back into your box.

Where is the entrance located?

You don't enter through the hotel lobby. Descend the outdoor staircase on Bishop Street beside the AC Hotel, which leads directly beneath street level into the bar.

What style of drinks do they serve?

The front bar focuses on modern craft cocktails, while the secret backroom commits to tiki classics and tropical house originals like Painkillers, Saturns, and Navy Grogs served in themed glassware.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: waikikibeachstays.com · Official site · hawaiimagazine.com · savvy360.com

last checked: 2026-11-17