El Modelo Block — Haunted & Secret History in Jacksonville & Mayport
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 53 — the Jacksonville & Mayport file — filed under: miscellanea

El Modelo Block

This former cigar factory survived the Great Fire of 1901. A Spanish-American War veteran was fatally shot at the property in 1907 and is said to haunt it.

→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in Jacksonville & Mayport — never the same twice

The story

Before Ybor City took the crown, Jacksonville ran a bustling Cuban tobacco pipeline, and Gabriel Hidalgo-Gato's El Modelo Cigar Manufacturing Company was the titan of the district. Built around 1888 on West Bay Street, the three-story brick block housed upwards of 200 rollers turning out roughly six million hand-rolled cigars a year. The building wasn't just industrial real estate; it was an ideological nerve center. Cuban revolutionary leader José Martí walked into this exact building on multiple occasions throughout the 1890s, giving fiery stump speeches directly to the factory floor to raise funds and recruits for Cuba's fight against Spanish rule.

When the catastrophic Great Fire of 1901 leveled 146 city blocks of downtown Jacksonville in eight hours, El Modelo was one of the freakishly few commercial brick structures left standing amid the embers. The cigar trade faded shortly after, and the block transitioned into the Plaza Hotel, with its ground level split into rough waterfront saloons catering to rail travelers and dock hands. That is when the building took its grim turn: in 1907, a Spanish-American War veteran crossed the threshold into one of the ground-floor barrooms looking for a drink. Before he could speak to the barkeep, someone leveled a sawed-off shotgun and shot him dead in the chest. Local legend holds that his shade still roams the building, eternally waiting for the round he never received.

After decades spent as a transient hotel and gritty rental block, the property was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1980 and eventually converted into professional offices. While modern legal practices now occupy the space, you can still see the stoic, soot-tinged masonry that defied Jacksonville's worst inferno and sheltered early revolutionists.

What it's like

El Modelo is an active, private office building rather than an open-door haunted attraction, so do not show up looking for late-night paranormal tours or public museum rooms. The primary draw is strictly architectural and historical: study the heavy late-19th-century commercial brickwork from the sidewalk along West Bay Street, or slip quietly into the main ground-floor entry during standard weekday office hours to view the curated mural depicting José Martí and the factory's tobacco legacy. It is a subtle, self-guided stop best enjoyed as a daylight walk-by before ducking into the rest of downtown.

The move: Walk the West Bay Street sidewalk, look up at the brickwork that survived the 1901 fire, and picture José Martí giving a speech to a factory floor full of cigar rollers.

Where: 501–513 West Bay Street, Jacksonville, FL

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Old City Cemetery of Jacksonville — Pair this stop with a walk through the cemetery that also survived the 1901 fire, where you will find the grave of Marie Louise Gato—the tragically murdered teenage daughter of El Modelo's founder.
  • The Volstead — Head three blocks east into downtown to drink a proper vintage cocktail that the unlucky veteran shot at El Modelo never got to taste.
  • Florida Casket Company building — Walk less than half a mile north into LaVilla to see another surviving turn-of-the-century industrial relic wrapped in Jacksonville urban legend.

More weird in Jacksonville & Mayport

Good to know

Can you tour the inside of El Modelo Block?

No formal tours exist. The upper floors and suites are private legal and corporate offices. However, you can step into the ground-floor lobby area during regular weekday business hours to view the historical mural honoring José Martí and the building's cigar-making history.

How did the building survive the Great Fire of 1901?

Its solid exterior brick masonry and location on the western periphery of downtown helped it escape the catastrophic firestorm that wiped out over 2,300 mostly wooden structures across Jacksonville on May 3, 1901.

What is the story behind the 1907 shooting?

During the building's rough post-cigar era as a hotel and saloon hub, an unnamed Spanish-American War veteran entered the saloon door and was fatally shot in the chest with a sawed-off shotgun before he could order a drink. Local lore claims his ghost still haunts the property.

What was El Modelo originally used for?

It opened in the late 1880s as Gabriel Hidalgo-Gato's El Modelo Cigar Manufacturing Company, Jacksonville's largest cigar factory, producing millions of cigars annually with hundreds of Cuban immigrant workers.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: folioweekly.com · npgallery.nps.gov · npshistory.com · jaxtoday.org · news4jax.com · thejaxsonmag.com

last checked: 2026-11-17