Grave of Large Marge — Haunted & Secret History in Jacksonville & Mayport

Entry No. 63 — the Jacksonville & Mayport file — filed under: miscellanea

Grave of Large Marge

Roadside America lists this unusually named grave among its offbeat Jacksonville sights. The supplied listing identifies it by name and city.

→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in Jacksonville & Mayport — never the same twice

The story

If you grew up anywhere near a television in the late 1980s, Alice Nunn gave you at least one acute nightmare. Her two-minute monologue as phantom trucker Large Marge in Tim Burton's 1985 classic *Pee-wee's Big Adventure*—quietly recounting 'the worst accident I ever seen' before her claymation eyeballs launched from their sockets—remains one of cult cinema's most indelible jump scares. Nunn spent over three decades working steadily as a character actress on stage and television, appearing on sitcoms like *Camp Runamuck* and *Petticoat Junction* and in films like *Mommie Dearest*. Yet it was that solitary, unhinged cab ride that permanently etched her into pop-culture memory.

When Nunn suffered a fatal heart attack in her West Hollywood apartment in July 1988 at age 60, her body was brought back across the country to her hometown of Jacksonville. She was interred in Old City Cemetery, an 1852 burial ground that miraculously survived the Great Fire of 1901. The cemetery is best known for yellow fever mass graves, Victorian crypts, and Confederate monuments, making Nunn one of the yard's most modern and thoroughly anomalous permanent residents.

There is no claymation tribute or neon truck marker. Nunn rests beneath a simple granite stone set completely flush with the lawn, inscribed only with her birth name and dates: 'ALICE ELIZABETH NUNN / OCTOBER 10, 1927 / JULY 1, 1988,' placed right alongside family. For the movie pilgrims who track down the plot to pay tribute and whisper 'tell 'em Large Marge sent ya,' the sheer disconnect between the quiet, moss-heavy Victorian graveyard and childhood cinematic trauma is the whole point.

What it's like

Old City Cemetery feels less like an open-air museum and more like a half-forgotten municipal secret. Entering through the gates off East Union Street puts you among broken curbing, sprawling live oaks, and thick Spanish moss. Because Nunn's headstone is completely flat to the turf under the canopy near the front section of the grounds, it is easy to walk right past it while staring up at the towering 19th-century obelisks. Grounds maintenance can be patchy, so wear closed-toe shoes to handle high grass and fire ants, visit in daylight, and check gate accessibility before making a special trek.

The move: Enter Old City Cemetery off East Union Street and see which of you spots Alice Nunn’s flat headstone first beneath the mossy oaks, then trade your best Large Marge impressions.

Where: Old City Cemetery, 601 E. Union St., Jacksonville, FL 32202 (Old City Cemetery / East Union St. entrance)

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Duuuval Walls mural tunnel — A five-minute walk south leads to this historic underpass lined with modern street murals, offering an energetic artistic counterweight to the crumbling Victorian grounds.
  • Old St. Luke’s Hospital — Located just half a mile down Palmetto Street, this 19th-century brick medical facility shares Old City Cemetery's yellow fever era roots and lingering ghost lore.
  • Florida Theatre Ghost Seats — Keep the phantom cinema theme running downtown at this 1927 movie palace, where two balcony seats are permanently left to the resident theatre ghost.
  • Dos Gatos — Wind down after walking the graveyard by ducking into this dimly lit cocktail lounge directly across from the Florida Theatre.

More weird in Jacksonville & Mayport

Good to know

Where in Old City Cemetery is Alice Nunn buried?

Her grave is located in the front area of the cemetery under the shade of the live oaks. Because it is a flat ground-level marker rather than a standing headstone, you will need to scan the turf directly.

Does the gravestone say 'Large Marge'?

No. The marker is strictly personal and traditional, reading only 'ALICE ELIZABETH NUNN' alongside her birth and death dates.

Is Old City Cemetery free to enter?

Yes, it is a public historic cemetery with no admission charge, though the gates are generally only accessible during standard daylight hours.

What should I watch out for while visiting?

The cemetery suffers from deferred maintenance. Watch your step for uneven ground, sunken markers, and fire-ant mounds, and plan to go during mid-day when downtown foot traffic is active.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: Roadside America · Wikipedia · thejaxsonmag.com · YouTube

last checked: 2026-11-17