
Entry No. 48 — the Jacksonville & Mayport file — filed under: miscellanea
TacoLu Baja Mexicana
The restaurant occupies an old two-story log cabin where Alpha Paynter ran a boarding house. Folio Weekly says she is buried on the grounds, and local lore places her ghost near the main dining room’s fireplace.
→ Three at a time, never the same twice — explore weird Jacksonville & Mayport
The story
In 1932, a businesswoman named Alpha Paynter put up a two-story pine log cabin along Beach Boulevard. She initially ran the building as a quiet boarding house before converting it in 1947 into The Homestead, a roadside institution famed for Southern skillet cooking that endured for over half a century. Paynter ran the property until shortly before her death in 1962, and according to decades of local Beaches lore, she never truly departed. Regional legend insists she was buried right behind the building on the grounds.
When TacoLu founders Don and Debbie Nicol relocated their taco outpost into the vacant Homestead cabin in 2012, they inherited Paynter's ghost stories along with the notched-timber walls. Rather than a quiet boarding-house parlor, the interior is now bathed in folk art, Day of the Dead motifs, and an inventory of well over a hundred tequilas. Yet the ghost sightings have persisted through the shift: staff and diners regularly report unprompted temperature drops, flickering lights, phantom humming, and sightings of Paynter's apparition lingering beside the massive limestone fireplace in the main dining room.
What it's like
Do not show up expecting a hush-hush historic séance. The cabin is loud, fast-moving, and perpetually fragrant with wood smoke, carnitas, and freshly squeezed citrus. You'll be sitting on wood beneath heavy timber beams, squeezed in among Beaches locals putting away tacos and agave pours. Peak evening waits can easily run an hour or more, so slip in on a weekday afternoon or grab a seat immediately at the bar if you want to inspect the fireplace without jostling someone's margarita.
The move: Order carnitas tacos under the old pine beams, breathe in the wood smoke and fresh citrus, and see which of you checks the fireplace first for Alpha Paynter’s ghost.
- 📍 Jacksonville Beach
- 💸 $$
- ⚡ Up for anything
- 🌗 Indoors
Where: 1712 Beach Blvd, Jacksonville Beach, FL 32250
Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.
Pair it with
- Ginger’s Place — Continue your Jacksonville Beach haunt tour at this dive bar a mile away, famously said to be haunted by its own departed founder and burlesque dancer, Ginger Payson.
- Beaches Museum & Historic Pablo Park — Head a mile east to this local history compound, whose archives preserve the only known historical photograph of Alpha Paynter alongside early 20th-century rail artifacts.
- Flask & Cannon — Trade rustic log-cabin agave spirits for flaming rum concoctions at this ocean-adjacent tiki den just 1.2 miles down the road.
More weird in Jacksonville & Mayport
Good to know
Is Alpha Paynter actually buried on the property?
Local lore and regional publications have asserted for decades that Paynter was buried in the lot directly behind the cabin, though no grave marker exists on the grounds today.
Where in the restaurant do the ghost encounters happen?
Sightings and unexplainable occurrences cluster near three specific spots: beside the dining room's central limestone fireplace, along the stairs, and in the women's restroom.
What occupied the building before TacoLu?
The 1932 log cabin served as Alpha Paynter's boarding house and then The Homestead restaurant from 1947 until the early 2000s, followed by a short stint as Copper Top before TacoLu moved in in 2012.
Can you visit just for drinks?
Yes. TacoLu operates a full-service bar known for stocking one of the largest tequila and mezcal collections in Northeast Florida, with seating available first-come, first-served.
Plan a visit & invite your people →
Further reading: folioweekly.com · thejaxsonmag.com · moderncities.com · jacksonville.com · thecoastal.com · jaxdailyrecord.com
last checked: 2026-11-17


