C. Green's Haunted History House & Museum — Oddities & Curiosities in Orlando
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 30 — the Orlando file — filed under: weird museum

C. Green's Haunted History House & Museum

Located inside a 1900 home in America's oldest spiritualist enclave, this independent museum houses an obsessive private hoard of supernatural and macabre artifacts. Rooms feature Florida Skunk Ape casts, cursed doll vitrines, Voodoo altars, and Victorian death paraphernalia.

→ Three at a time, never the same twice — explore weird Orlando

The story

Most visitors head to Cassadaga expecting polite psychic readings and quiet porch swings, but this turn-of-the-century wood-frame building on Stevens Street takes a far less sanitized approach to the spirit realm. Originally the town's sole grocery store, the space was taken over in 1982 by June Benjamin, whose ashes still sit on a high shelf overlooking the back office. Today, her granddaughter Christina Green and wife Mel Carpenter—both avid ghost hunters—have turned the footprint into a sprawling, hyper-dense private archive of the occult, macabre, and unexplained.

Curated by store manager Varney Pearce, who got his start working in the funeral industry handling removals, the house operates as part archive and part roadside curiosity cabinet. The camp's founding history is anchored here by George P. Colby’s personal séance table, complete with a hand-tatted lace doily crafted by one of the Alderman family daughters. But right alongside legitimate late-19th-century Spiritualist artifacts, the rooms pivot wildly into Victorian safety coffins, electroshock medical equipment, casts of Florida Skunk Ape footprints, and files detailing the infamous I-4 Dead Zone.

What it's like

You enter off Stevens Street right through The Purple Rose Trading Company into a maze of tight, bookcase-partitioned rooms where the mechanical patter of a Madame Morbida fortune teller bleeds through the dividers. The front room is thick with antique porcelain dolls tagged with handwritten cards logging their reported paranormal quirks; staff will hand you an EMF reader to check the vitrines yourself. It is cramped, intentionally disorienting, and unapologetically cluttered.

The move: Explore the oddity-crammed parlor of historic séance ephemera and cryptid evidence, then take a quiet twilight walk through the camp's nearby fairy trail.

Where: 1079 Stevens Street, Cassadaga (Lake Helen), FL 32706

Hours: Added 2026-11-07 — confirm current hours before you go.

#weird museum #cryptids #haunted artifacts #cabinet of curiosities #spiritualism

Pair it with

  • Hotel Cassadaga — Walk down the street to the 1927 hotel where the Spiritualist Camp's working mediums hold readings and Arthur supposedly haunts the upper hallway.
  • Cassadaga Fairy Trail — Take a short woodland stroll through the town's folk-art trail to clear the parlor air among the miniature shrines and mossy oaks.
  • Jeanine Taylor Folk Art — Head south into Sanford to swap the occult hoard for curated Southern vernacular art and outsider woodcarvings.

More weird in Orlando

Good to know

Is the museum officially run by the Cassadaga Spiritualist Camp?

No. It is an independently owned, family-run roadside museum and oddities parlor operating within the borders of the town.

What is the most notable Cassadaga artifact in the collection?

The wooden séance table that belonged to George P. Colby, the trance medium who founded the Cassadaga Spiritualist Camp in 1894.

Are the haunted dolls just for display?

Most are museum pieces on view with their backstories detailed on handwritten cards, but select estate-sale dolls and oddities are offered for purchase to collectors.

Do you need special equipment to explore?

No, though you can carry an EMF meter through the rooms to scan the displays and doll cabinets for magnetic anomalies.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: uncoveringflorida.com · roadtripowl.com · Official site · beacononlinenews.com

last checked: 2026-11-07