The Church Cantina — Haunted & Secret History in Tacoma & South Sound
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 20 — the Tacoma & South Sound file — filed under: miscellanea

The Church Cantina

A gothic haven known for pairing dark, macabre aesthetics with Cuban fare, while regularly hosting spooky subculture events and indie zine launch parties.

→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in Tacoma & South Sound — never the same twice

The story

When chef Nicole de la Paz and partner Adam Jones took over a former pizza joint on South Tacoma Way in 2018, their operating blueprint was simple: open a room they actually wanted to hang out in, which strictly meant no sports broadcasts and post-punk on repeat. De la Paz, a seasoned cook who ran lines at regional mainstays like Dirty Oscar's Annex and Marrow, designed a kitchen where slow-braised Cuban street fare could share floor space with a deeply loyal gothic subculture.

What could have been a kitschy novelty instead turned into an anchor for South Tacoma's alternative community. The room leans into dim crimson lighting, subverted religious iconography, and horror ephemera, but the food is treated with dead seriousness. Slow-roasted mojo pork and pressed Cubano sandwiches share equal billing with an exhaustive plant-based menu featuring house-seasoned jackfruit, vegan chorizo, and dairy-free queso. Between local zine launches, horror trivia, and darkwave DJ nights, the room operates as equal parts dive bar, community center, and late-night haven.

What it's like

You step off South Tacoma Way into dim, low-lit gloom soundtracked by The Cure, darkwave, or 80s synth. The floor is lined with cozy booths and horror art, populated by a neighborhood mix of goths, vinyl fiends, and locals who simply know it has some of the best pressed sandwiches in Pierce County. Service is bar-forward and laid-back. The space is intimate, so if an indie market, zine party, or DJ night is on the calendar, grab a booth early before the room packs out.

The move: Slide into a booth under the dim crimson gloom, order slow-roasted mojo pork and a pressed Cubano to share, and let the post-punk and horror art set the mood.

Where: 5240 South Tacoma Way, Tacoma, WA 98409

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Tacoma's Haunted Farmers Market — Browse the oddities, candles, and handmade macabre wares at the market before settling into the cantina's booths for mojo pork and dark tunes.
  • Black Bird Apothecary — Hit this South Tacoma metaphysical shop for ritual supplies and dried herbs before walking a few steps over to the cantina for a rum cocktail.
  • Bob’s Java Jive — Pair your gothic Cuban dinner with a quick drive up South Tacoma Way to drink inside a landmark 1927 giant concrete teapot.

More weird in Tacoma & South Sound

Good to know

What kind of food does The Church Cantina serve?

The kitchen centers on Cuban- and Latin-inspired comfort food, including mojo pork bowls, pressed Cubano sandwiches, tostones, and black bean platters.

Is it friendly for vegans and vegetarians?

Extremely. Roughly half the menu caters to plant-based diners, offering jackfruit Cubanos, vegan chorizo nachos, and dairy-free sauces without treating vegan food as an afterthought.

What kind of programming happens here?

The venue routinely hosts alternative culture events, ranging from goth and darkwave DJ nights to indie zine releases, art pop-ups, and trivia.

Is it all ages?

The venue operates primarily as a bar-lounge; evenings and special event nights are 21 and over.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: seattle.eater.com · thenewstribune.com · Facebook · Official site · the-church-cantina.eniplaces.com

last checked: 2026-11-17