El Paso Playhouse — Haunted & Secret History in El Paso & Fort Bliss
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 37 — the El Paso & Fort Bliss file — filed under: miscellanea

El Paso Playhouse

A community theater operating inside a former church, the venue is allegedly haunted by a technician who was accidentally killed during an onstage performance in its early days. Staff and paranormal investigators have recorded electronic voice phenomena alongside reports of disembodied whispers near concessions, self-flushing restrooms, and footsteps echoing on the wooden stairs.

→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in El Paso & Fort Bliss — never the same twice

The story

Before it became El Paso's longest-running community theater, the building at the corner of Montana Avenue and Magnolia Street was an active neighborhood church. In 1965, the sanctuary was purchased and renovated into the Festival Theatre, which eventually joined forces with another local troupe, the Upstairs Theatre, to establish the El Paso Playhouse. The sanctuary bones never entirely disappeared: the layout retains the tight backstage passages, the echoes of high ceilings, and steep wooden stairs that carry every creak across the house.

Community theater is inherently steeped in superstitions, but the lore at 2501 Montana carries a darker anchor: an accident in the theater's early days in which a stage technician was killed during a live performance. Ever since, stagehands and actors have claimed he remained on crew. Props set down on workbenches vanish only to reappear months later inside locked cabinets. A resident spirit nicknamed Thomas is blamed for knocking against cabinet doors in the woodshop, while stage managers working late have recounted doors bolting from the inside.

The oddities aren't just backstage folklore whispered among cast members. When investigators from the Research in Paranormal Science of El Paso (RIPS) swept the dark auditorium, their recorders captured multiple electronic voice phenomena—faint, unprompted whispers registering in the empty theater and the women's restroom. Paired with independent reports of phantom footsteps marching up the wooden stairs, disembodied murmurs near the concession stand, and bathroom fixtures running on their own, the Playhouse lives up to its reputation as one of Central El Paso's most active historic spaces.

What it's like

You are walking into an unvarnished, tight-knit community theater with roughly a hundred seats, where the stage is mere feet from the front row and volunteer staff run both the box office and the concession counter. The atmosphere is intimate and distinctly low-tech—expect creaky floorboards, the hum of stage lights, and an acoustic environment so resonant that every bump backstage carries right into the house. Arrive early enough to grab a soda and candy at concessions, and pay attention to the silence between scenes or along the stairwells.

The move: Squeeze into the roughly hundred-seat former church sanctuary, with the stage mere feet away, and listen for footsteps on the steep wooden stairs and whispers near the concession counter.

Where: 2501 Montana Ave, El Paso, TX 79903

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Monteleone's Ristorante — Double down on Central El Paso's ghost circuit by chasing a curtain call with a plate of pasta at an Italian spot whose dining room is famously claimed to sit on a spiritual portal.
  • L&J Cafe (“The Old Place by the Graveyard”) — Grab fiery red chile enchiladas and a beer across from Concordia Cemetery before heading a mile west on Montana Avenue for curtain time.
  • Concordia Cemetery & John Wesley Hardin Grave — Spend the late afternoon walking through 54 acres of desert graves and Old West history before sitting in the creaky pews of the Playhouse for the evening show.

More weird in El Paso & Fort Bliss

Good to know

What kind of shows does the El Paso Playhouse produce?

The venue runs a year-round slate of volunteer-driven community theater, rotating through classic plays, comedies, modern dramas, and seasonal ghost stories like Bram Stoker's Dracula or The Haunting of Hill House.

What specific hauntings have been reported here?

Frequent reports include heavy footsteps pacing the wooden staircase when nobody is on it, disembodied whispers near the concession booth, self-flushing restroom plumbing, props mysteriously shifting locations, and sudden cold spots onstage.

Has the building been examined by paranormal investigators?

Yes. Groups including the Research in Paranormal Science of El Paso (RIPS) have conducted formal investigations of the building, documenting several audio recordings of electronic voice phenomena (EVPs) in the house and the ladies' room.

How do tickets and seating work?

Tickets can be purchased online or at the box office on performance nights, typically priced around $12 to $15 with discounts for students, seniors, and military. Seating is general admission within an intimate auditorium.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: kisselpaso.com · theprospectordaily.com · klaq.com · Official site · scholarworks.utep.edu

last checked: 2026-11-17