Monteleone's Ristorante — Occult & Mystical in El Paso & Fort Bliss
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 27 — the El Paso & Fort Bliss file — filed under: miscellanea

Monteleone's Ristorante

A storied Italian restaurant where patrons can 'dine with the dead,' renowned for its resident ghosts and reputedly dubbed a spiritual portal by a psychic.

→ Three at a time, never the same twice — explore weird El Paso & Fort Bliss

The story

When Gary Monteleone—a former Hollywood prop and set designer—returned to El Paso and opened an Italian eatery in 2001, he aimed to serve his grandmother’s Reggio Calabria family recipes in an ambiance styled after a 1930s speakeasy. Things took an involuntary turn toward the bizarre during an expansion into the adjoining space. While tearing down a false wall, workers uncovered the relics of a 1920s Spiritualist church that had once operated seances on the spot. Almost immediately, the staff reported phantom footfalls, candles igniting on their own, and a small statuette of the Virgin Mary that consistently rotated itself 180 degrees to face the wall whenever left unattended.

Word spread, psychics investigated, and the consensus among the occult-minded was that knocking down the wall had inadvertently breached a spiritual portal. Tales of shadow figures in the restrooms, an apparition with no feet, and an arm materializing to grab at the owner through the glass door eventually prompted SyFy's 'Paranormal Witness' to feature the restaurant in a 2013 episode titled 'Dining with the Dead'. Rather than fleeing the property, Monteleone leaned into it, cementing the restaurant's reputation as a rare joint where you can order tortiglioni while eavesdropping on alleged ectoplasm.

What it's like

You spot the place immediately off Gateway Boulevard West by the giant relief sculpture of a fedora-wearing mobster mounted above the front entrance. Step inside and you are plunged into deep red lighting, heavy fabrics, vintage gangster memorabilia, and crowded dining booths surrounded by theatrical knick-knacks. The pacing is old-school: service moves deliberately, the portions of homemade pasta and garlic rolls are hefty, and the dining room operates with very limited seating. The restaurant typically runs short evening hours only a few nights a week (historically Thursday through Saturday), so showing up without a reservation is a guaranteed gamble.

The move: Find the fedora-wearing mobster sculpture above the door off Gateway Boulevard West, slide into a red-lit booth, and share homemade pasta while watching for any statuette of the Virgin Mary turning toward the wall.

Where: 3023 Gateway Blvd W, El Paso, TX 79903

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Concordia Cemetery & John Wesley Hardin Grave — Spend the afternoon hunting the iron-caged grave of outlaw John Wesley Hardin in this 54-acre necropolis before heading three minutes down the road to dine alongside rumored spirits.
  • El Paso Playhouse — Pair your haunted pasta with an evening show at this community theater inside a former church, which comes with its own tragic resident ghost story.
  • Ho Baron Sculpture Garden — Stop by this surreal residential corner lot blanketed in bizarre, bronze-cast mythological totems before your dinner reservation across the highway.

More weird in El Paso & Fort Bliss

Good to know

Why is the restaurant believed to be haunted?

During renovations, owners uncovered artifacts from an old 1920s Spiritualist church behind a false wall, which local paranormal lore claims acted as an active portal for disembodied spirits.

What kind of food do they serve?

Southern Italian comfort food, including lasagna, tortiglioni with sautéed zucchini, Italian wedding soup, and house-baked bread based on recipes from the owner's grandmother.

Do I need a reservation to eat here?

Yes. Seating is tight and the restaurant only operates dinner service on select evenings toward the end of the week, making reservations strongly recommended.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: texashighways.com · cbs4local.com · syfy.com · hauntedrooms.com

last checked: 2026-11-17