Bail for Tails — Hands-On & Workshops in Fayetteville & Fort Liberty

Entry No. 47 — the Fayetteville & Fort Liberty file — filed under: miscellanea

Bail for Tails

This cat rescue sits next door to Awesome Tattoos. WRAL describes it as a place to stop and pet a kitten.

→ Three at a time, never the same twice — explore weird Fayetteville & Fort Liberty

The story

You wouldn't typically link the Cumberland County judicial system to stray kittens, but Bail for Tails was born out of that exact intersection. Founder Dianne Carrillo was working as a downtown Fayetteville bail bond agent when she found herself constantly crossing paths with the neighborhood's neglected alley cats. She spent off-hours trapping, vetting, and finding homes for them until the feline caseload outgrew the day job, prompting her to trade posting criminal bail for running 'Bail for Tails' as a dedicated nonprofit rescue.

Tucked into 5 Market Square right against the downtown circle, the rescue anchors its physical presence as a hybrid donation thrift store and outpost. Unlike municipal shelters with endless kennels, the rescue operates on a 100% foster-based framework, funneling proceeds from donated clothes and curios directly into food, veterinary care, and foster supplies across Cumberland County.

Its placement next door to Awesome Tattoos gave rise to one of the district's best accidental walk-in routines: killing time before a tattoo appointment by dropping into the thrift space to visit whichever foster cats or kittens happen to be holding court on the retail floor.

What it's like

Expect the dense, cluttered charm of a genuine volunteer thrift store rather than a polished retail boutique. Racks of secondhand clothes, donated housewares, and pet supplies share floor space with kitten playpens, scratching posts, and volunteers sorting donations. The vibe is quiet and informal; you might find a sleepy kitten curled behind the counter or a foster waiting for a ride, but verify their operating hours before you swing by, as opening times fluctuate with volunteer availability.

The move: Pick out the oddest donated houseware you can find for each other, then ask a volunteer if there’s a kitten you can pet.

Where: 5 Market Square, Fayetteville, NC 28301

Hours: Added 2026-11-18 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Awesome Tattoos — Sitting directly next door on Market Square, this tattoo parlor shares an unspoken routine where clients stop in to pet foster kittens to calm their nerves before going under the needle.
  • Winterbloom Tea — Stroll around the block to Hay Street to pair your thrift-store cat visits with loose-leaf tea brews or evening botanical cocktails.
  • Circa 1800 — Turn onto Person Street just off Market Square for North Carolina farm-to-table cooking and regional moonshines.
  • Marker: Babe Ruth’s First Home Run — Right around the circle on Gillespie Street, you can spot the state historical marker commemorating Babe Ruth's first professional home run hit in 1914.

More weird in Fayetteville & Fort Liberty

Good to know

Where did the name 'Bail for Tails' come from?

Founder Dianne Carrillo was a local bail bondsman in downtown Fayetteville before launching the rescue around 2019. After years of trapping and rehoming street cats between bond assignments, she traded posting jail bail for springing homeless animals.

Is this a walk-in cat café or shelter?

Neither. The Market Square storefront functions primarily as a donation thrift store that supports the rescue. While foster cats and kittens frequently hang out in the shop for socialization, Bail for Tails places most of its rescues in foster homes and adopts through applications or partner locations like Farmer's Cat Cafe.

Can you actually pet cats before getting a tattoo next door?

Yes, provided foster animals are on site and volunteers are open. The shop sits directly adjacent to Awesome Tattoos, making a quick kitten cuddle an established rite of passage for nervous tattoo clients.

How does buying something here help the animals?

The shop is 100% donation- and foster-driven. Every dollar spent on thrift goods goes toward vet bills, trap-neuter-return work, litter, and food for homeless cats in Fayetteville.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: wral.com · taxexemptworld.com · intellispect.co · chewy.com · upandcomingweekly.com · cityviewnc.com

last checked: 2026-11-18