
Entry No. 33 — the Great Lakes & North Shore file — filed under: miscellanea
The Baker House
This opulent 1885 lakefront Queen Anne mansion and former sanitarium cottage is reputed to be haunted by a ghostly gentleman with a handlebar mustache and a spectral 'Lady in White.'
→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in Great Lakes & North Shore — never the same twice
The story
In 1885, Emily Baker—the wealthy widow of J.I. Case tractor partner and Wisconsin state senator Robert Hall Baker—spared no expense erecting what she called Redwood Cottage directly on the Lake Geneva shoreline. Her husband had died three years earlier, never seeing the finished 17,000-square-foot Queen Anne manor, which was framed and clad in rare California redwood hauled across the country by rail. Inside, craftworkers installed thirteen distinct tiled fireplaces, elaborate parquetry rumored to have been laid by S.C. Johnson himself, and sweeping lakeside verandas designed to telegraph Gilded Age dominion over the water.
The Baker family's domestic tenure did not last long. Following Emily's death in 1894, the estate was sold off and absorbed into the resort town's booming sanitarium trade. Rechristened Lakeside Cottage, it served as an annex of the nearby Oakwood sanitarium complex, housing affluent Chicagoans sent up north to recover from "nervous disorders" and chemical dependencies. Decades of restless reinvention followed—a discreet speakeasy during Prohibition, followed by a long mid-century run as the St. Moritz hotel and restaurant—before a 2010 restoration returned it to Gilded Age excess. Along the way, the property collected ghost stories: motion-activated security cameras regularly trigger on the old servants' staircase, where staff have reported a translucent "Lady in White" drifting through doorways, while overnight guests still claim to encounter a spectral gentleman sporting a vintage handlebar mustache roaming the corridors.
What it's like
Expect a collision of Gilded Age melodrama, haunted-manor camp, and high-end cocktail lounge. The interior is dense with jewel-toned velvet, antique furnishings, and low chandelier glow, but the house's defining parlor trick is its collection of vintage millinery: dozens of period hats and feathered fascinators hang along the hallway pegs, and guests are openly invited to grab one and wear it while drinking. It draws a spirited mix of weekend lake tourists, anniversary celebrants, and paranormal seekers. Drop by on a weeknight for a drink at the Ringmaster Bar or out on the lake-view lawn to beat the private-event crowds, and keep an eye on the staircase if the lights flicker.
The move: Grab a vintage period hat or feathered fascinator from the hallway pegs and wander past thirteen tiled fireplaces and jewel-toned velvet inside this haunted 1885 lakefront Queen Anne mansion.
- 📍 Lake Geneva, WI
- 💸 $$
- ⚡ Up for anything
- 🌗 Indoors
Where: 327 Wrigley Dr, Lake Geneva, WI 53147
Hours: Added 2026-11-18 — confirm current hours before you go.
Pair it with
- Black Point Estate and Gardens — Hop a boat across Geneva Lake to tour another 1888 Queen Anne summer retreat built for a Chicago baron, famous for its preserved Victorian interiors and spiritualist séances.
- Kemper Center — Head east to Kenosha's shoreline for another sprawling nineteenth-century lakefront complex soaked in regional ghost folklore.
- Lehmann Mansion & Lake Villa Grounds — Contrast the Baker House's Queen Anne woodwork with the imposing neoclassical columns of a Chicago retail tycoon's 1912 summer playground across the state line.
More weird in Great Lakes & North Shore
Good to know
Do you need to book an overnight room to see inside?
No. While the upper floors operate as boutique suites, the ground-floor lounges, restaurant, and lakefront garden are open to the public for dinner, drinks, and weekend dining.
What is the story behind the vintage hats in the hallways?
The house keeps dozens of antique and vintage hats on display pegs throughout the common areas, which visitors are encouraged to pick up, wear around the mansion, and photograph during their visit.
How much of the original 1885 structure survives?
A remarkable amount: all thirteen original tiled fireplaces remain intact, alongside intricate carved woodwork, inlaid hardwood floors, and original California redwood siding that is still visible on the exterior turret.
Are ghost tours allowed on the property?
Local Lake Geneva ghost walks frequently stop outside on the sidewalk to recount the house's sanitarium lore, and the mansion itself occasionally hosts ticketed historical and haunted tours during the fall season.
Plan a visit & invite your people →
Further reading: Official site · atthelakemagazine.com · visitlakegeneva.com · hauntedwisconsin.com · Wikipedia · Atlas Obscura
last checked: 2026-11-18


