Pablo-Mayport Cemetery — Haunted & Secret History in Jacksonville & Mayport
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 47 — the Jacksonville & Mayport file — filed under: miscellanea

Pablo-Mayport Cemetery

Andrew Dewees and members of his family are buried here. The supplied material connects Dewees to the Spanish land grant on which Mayport Village sits and mentions a past tour of the cemetery.

→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in Jacksonville & Mayport — never the same twice

The story

Tucked past the southern edge of Wonderwood Drive at the dead end of Sand Castle Lane, Pablo-Mayport Cemetery sits on a fragment of the sprawling 1792 Spanish land grant awarded to Andrew Dewees. Dewees's orange plantation and timber acreage eventually fragmented into the village of Mayport, and this sandy hammock became the final resting place for the families who pulled the settlement out of the tidal marsh—the Deweeses, Floyds, Arnaus, and the maritime dynasty of the Singletons, including centenarian Lily Singleton Thomas.

The cemetery holds far more than what sits above the turf. Phase I archaeological surveys picked up prehistoric toolmaking debitage and subsurface soil signatures pointing to an ancient Indigenous mound on the property. By the late 19th century, the grounds took in victims of coastal yellow fever epidemics, interred with humble wooden markers that rotted into dust generations ago. The earliest legible stone dates to 1881, but local historians suspect earlier graves along the margins were quietly swallowed when tidal tributaries of the St. Johns River shifted course.

Don't trust the perimeter fences. Ground-penetrating radar sweeps conducted by archaeologists from the University of North Florida and the Florida Public Archaeology Network proved that historical burials stretch well beyond the modern chain link. More strangely, radar scans confirmed long-standing local rumors: older marble and coquina headstones had occasionally been buried face-down beneath the topsoil to level out ground and make space for newer plots.

What it's like

You are driving into a quiet residential cul-de-sac where the pavement gives way to a scrub-oak hammock. Parking is tight on the shoulder—do not block neighborhood driveways. The cemetery itself is an intimate, quiet acre draped in Spanish moss and resurrection ferns, cared for by the Mayport Cemetery Association. Aside from the occasional Beaches Museum history walking tour, you will likely have the grounds completely to yourself. Wear closed-toe shoes and insect repellent; coastal sandspurs and gnats thrive in the grass.

The move: Follow Sand Castle Lane to its dead end, then look for the Dewees graves beneath the Spanish moss on a scrap of the family’s 1792 Spanish land grant.

Where: South end of Sand Castle Lane (south of Wonderwood Drive), Mayport area / Jacksonville, FL 32233 (no single street number found)

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Singleton’s Seafood Shack — Pay respects to the Singleton family plots here under the oaks, then drive two miles north to eat Mayport shrimp at the weathered plywood fish camp they built on the river docks.
  • King House — Several generations of the King family rest in Pablo Cemetery, making a drive past their two-story 19th-century boarding house down in Mayport Village a direct historical continuation.
  • Voo Swar — Follow this neglected slice of coastal pioneer history with a cold beer at a historic juke joint that preserved safe harbor for Black sailors during the Jim Crow era.

More weird in Jacksonville & Mayport

Good to know

Who owns and manages Pablo-Mayport Cemetery?

It is a privately owned community burial ground maintained by the Mayport Cemetery Association.

How old are the earliest graves?

The oldest surviving marked tombstone is dated 1881, though unrecorded pioneer burials, yellow fever victims, and older unmarked Dewees family plots date back significantly earlier.

Can the public visit whenever they want?

The grounds are accessible during daylight hours, but because it sits directly at the end of a residential street, visitors should be respectful of neighbors and keep visits strictly between sunrise and sunset.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: fpangoingpublic.blogspot.com · beachesmuseum.org · jacksonville.com · bradshawcarter.com · calameo.com

last checked: 2026-11-17