Sunbright Inn — Haunted & Secret History in Pensacola & Emerald Coast

Entry No. 67 — the Pensacola & Emerald Coast file — filed under: miscellanea

Sunbright Inn

Once the residence of former Florida Governor Sidney J. Catts, this historic manor is reputed in local lore to be haunted by the spirits of the governor and his wife.

→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in Pensacola & Emerald Coast — never the same twice

The story

In 1886, Wisconsin railroad magnate James T. Sherman arrived in Walton County to winter near the newly established Florida Chautauqua Assembly. On a high rise overlooking the town, he built a 6,000-square-foot Queen Anne manor, punched 52 double-hung sash windows into the walls to capture the winter sunlight, and christened it Sunbright. But the estate earned its stranger reputation in the 1920s, when Alice Catts acquired the deed and moved in her husband: Sidney Johnston Catts, Florida's 22nd governor. Catts was an armed, combative Baptist preacher who rode into Tallahassee on the Prohibition Party ticket with a pistol strapped to his waist. He upgraded the manor with Walton County's very first indoor plumbing system, survived multiple federal indictments, and ultimately died inside the house in 1936.

Following Alice Catts' death in 1949, the home suffered decades of decline. It was partitioned into cramped apartments, stripped of its ornate gingerbread cresting, and repainted haphazardly, though it still landed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1979 under its local moniker, the Catts House. Throughout its mid-century decay and later turns as a bed-and-breakfast, unprompted stories dogged the address. Long recognized in regional folklore as one of Walton County's most haunted structures, visitors reported latched doors swinging wide on their own, abrupt cold spots in still hallways, and phantom footsteps attributed to the late governor pacing the floorboards.

In 2023, local restorers took on the massive overhaul of the decaying property. They peeled away decades of slapdash drywall, soundproofed the interior, revived its bold sunflower-yellow exterior, and reopened the manor as an eight-room boutique inn. While the infrastructure is thoroughly modern, the original brick chimneys, towering pocket doors, and peculiar atmosphere remain firmly in place.

What it's like

Arriving here feels less like checking into a hotel and more like trespassing politely into an unattended private estate. There is no front desk and no concierge waiting to hand you a physical key; entry codes for the gate, front door, and your room are sent directly to your phone the day of arrival, allowing you to walk straight inside without seeing another soul. Inside, eight themed rooms feature dark Victorian wallpapers, period antiques, and clawfoot soaking tubs, buffered from exterior noise by heavy soundproofing. The ground-floor Governor's Suite is the standout, anchored by Catts' original exposed brick fireplace and an en-suite bath set into the bay window. Note that breakfast is not served on the property, but downtown DeFuniak Springs' cafes are an easy eight-minute walk down Live Oak Avenue.

The move: Use the codes on your phone to let yourselves into the old Queen Anne manor, then pick a sash window and trade the ghost stories about Governor Catts and his wife.

Where: 30 Live Oak Ave W, DeFuniak Springs, FL 32435

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Fountain of Youth & Lake DeFuniak — A short downhill stroll brings you to the perfectly circular spring-fed lake that lured 1880s Chautauqua travelers to DeFuniak Springs and prompted Sherman to build Sunbright.
  • Hotel DeFuniak — Walk four blocks east to compare Sunbright's polished quiet with DeFuniak's other historic haunt, an offbeat 1920s hotel with its own paranormal legacy in Room 8.
  • Chautauqua Hall of Brotherhood — Pair your stay with the colossal lakeside auditorium where Gilded Age crowds gathered for lectures while the town's prominent winter residents retreated to hilltops like Sunbright.
  • Vortex Spring & Cavern Basin — Trade historic wainscoting and ghost stories for deep water by heading fifteen minutes east to swim or dive in a 68-degree limestone cavern basin.

More weird in Pensacola & Emerald Coast

Good to know

Who was Governor Sidney J. Catts?

Catts served as Florida's governor from 1917 to 1921, notable as the only person in state history elected on the Prohibition Party ticket. Famous for fiery rhetoric and carrying a sidearm on the campaign trail, he retired to DeFuniak Springs and lived at Sunbright until his death inside the house in 1936.

What paranormal activity is reported here?

Long cited in local lore as one of the most haunted sites in DeFuniak Springs, visitors and past tenants have reported self-opening interior doors, disembodied footsteps, unexplained drafts, and lingering presences attributed to Governor Catts and his wife Alice.

How does check-in work without a front desk?

The inn uses a fully automated digital check-in system. You complete registration online prior to arrival and receive digital keypad codes by text message for the perimeter gate, main entrance, and your room.

Is breakfast provided during a stay?

No, Sunbright operates as an autonomous boutique inn rather than a traditional bed-and-breakfast. In-room coffee setups, refrigerators, and microwaves are provided, and downtown diners sit a few blocks away.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: Official site · nwfdailynews.com · yahoo.com · npgallery.nps.gov · authenticwalton.com

last checked: 2026-11-17