
Entry No. 33 — the Toronto, ON file — filed under: miscellanea
Vatican Gift Shop
A corner door inside a religious-trinket storefront at 1047 Gerrard St. E. opens into a red-lit bar with an imitation Sistine Chapel, a confessional window and a church pew by the performance platform.
→ Three more hidden bars & speakeasies in Toronto, ON — never the same twice
The story
From Gerrard Street East, 1047 looks like a tiny, solemn Catholic devotional shop crammed with crucifixes, rosaries, and votive candles. There is no flashy cocktail signage—just devotional clutter and the occasional house t-shirt on a shelf. But locate the Romanesque-arched door tucked into the back corner, push through it, and the piety instantly dissolves into something far less sacred.
Opened in late 2018 by Marc Baglio and Adam Kelly—the crew behind Gerrard East staples Pinkerton’s Snack Bar and Poor Romeo—the space is unexpectedly massive once you breach the threshold. The 130-capacity bar tunnels deep behind both the souvenir shop and the neighboring barbershop next door. Overhead, a UK-sourced replica of the Sistine Chapel ceiling hangs beneath low red lights and heavy chain lamps rescued from a churchware collector in Pennsylvania.
Rather than an aloof, whisper-only cocktail den, the room leans directly into cheek and revelry. Church pews double as banquettes near the performance platform, confessional-style partitions divide seating booths, and an open kitchen turns out blistered sourdough Neapolitan pies inspired by Nancy Silverton's dough recipes alongside a bar list dominated by amaro, spritzes, and local draughts.
What it's like
Push past the altar knick-knacks at the door and you step into a humming, crimson-drenched beer hall where the soundtrack quickly drowns out the street. Early in the evening it functions as a relaxed neighborhood pizza parlor where you can claim a confessional booth, split an amaro cocktail, and actually hold a conversation. As night falls—especially on live-band nights, DJ sets, or their riotous Wednesday karaoke sessions—the tables push back, the volume climbs, and the room packs in shoulder-to-shoulder with east-side regulars. Come before 8 p.m. if you want a table to eat; come later if you came to drink and dance under a fake Michelangelo.
The move: Pass the rosaries and votive candles, push through the arched corner door, and claim a confessional booth beneath the red-lit replica of the Sistine Chapel ceiling.
- 📍 Leslieville, Toronto
- 💸 $
- ⚡ Up for anything
- 🌗 Indoors
Where: 1047 Gerrard St E, Toronto, ON M4M 1Z7
Hours: Added 2026-11-18 — confirm current hours before you go.
Pair it with
- Distillery Historic District & Ghost Tours — Pair a lantern-led walk through Victorian distillery ruins with late-night amaro and sacrilege under a replica Sistine Chapel.
- Celsius — Follow an icy plunge into the lake from a floating sauna with warm blistered sourdough pizza and red-lit drinks on Gerrard East.
- Atlas Crane — Trade the windy industrial quiet of a derelict Port Lands crane for slipping through a devotional storefront into a crowded beer hall.
More weird in Toronto, ON
Good to know
How do you actually get inside?
Walk into the religious-goods storefront at 1047 Gerrard Street East and push straight through the arched Romanesque door tucked in the corner.
What is the food menu like?
It centers around thin-crust, sourdough Neapolitan-style pizzas alongside Italian-leaning snacks and street-food plates.
What kind of drinks do they serve?
The bar focuses heavily on Italian amari, inventive house cocktails, and rotating draughts from both local Toronto craft breweries and European taps.
Do they host live entertainment?
Yes—the church-pew stage regularly features live music acts, weekend DJs, and a weekly Wednesday-night karaoke session.
Plan a visit & invite your people →
Further reading: barmagazine.com · destinationontario.com · thecuriouscreature.com · blogto.com · curiocity.com
last checked: 2026-11-18


