
Entry No. 23 — the Watertown & Fort Drum file — filed under: miscellanea
Better Farm
A 65-acre organic farm, animal sanctuary, artist colony, and retreat space that features forests, rolling hills, open fields, and a pond.
→ Three at a time, never the same twice — explore weird Watertown & Fort Drum
The story
In 1970, Steve Caldwell—quadriplegic following a catastrophic auto wreck—retreated from New Jersey into the rough backwoods outside Redwood to purchase a 65-acre parcel of rocky soil, pond, and forest. Rather than resigning himself to nursing care, he opened up an intentional commune centered around the "Better Theory": a conviction that every derailment, disaster, or curveball offers raw material for exponential personal reinvention. Steve famously rolled his wheelchair up to seventeen miles a day on North Country birdwatching loops, published vanity-press poetry, and kept the farm open as a refuge for drifting artists and dropouts until his death in 2009.
The property passed to his niece, Nicole Caldwell, who promptly walked away from an editor-in-chief post at Playgirl magazine and a Brooklyn apartment to take the wheel with zero farming background. Over the following decade, she dragged the drafty 19th-century farmhouse into the modern era, converting the acreage into a solar-powered educational experiment, certified organic farm, and animal sanctuary. It operates today as a remarkably self-contained cultural colony: a two-story Art Barn with a gallery and recording space, vegetable test plots built from salvaged lumber, and paddocks harboring rescued chickens and alpacas.
The property also houses an improbable slice of independent media: WAIB 88.5 FM, a non-profit, volunteer-powered LPFM radio station broadcasting poetry, local music, and fishing reports from the farm out across the St. Lawrence tree canopy.
What it's like
This is a working communal sanctuary and homestead, so do not expect velvet ropes or a visitor center desk. When you pull into the driveway on Cottage Hill Road, you'll encounter a weathered farmhouse, raised beds cobbled from reclaimed window frames, and free-roaming rescue hens. The vibe is unpretentious and industrious—a mix of resident artists nursing studio projects, WWOOF volunteers shoveling compost, and overnight Hipcampers lingering over coffee in the shared kitchen. Tune your dial to 88.5 FM when you cross into Redwood; if you are visiting outside public concerts or the annual August Better Festival, arrange your tour or room booking in advance, as unannounced stragglers are likely to be handed gardening gloves and put to work.
The move: Pull up to the Cottage Hill Road farmhouse, wander past raised beds cobbled from reclaimed window frames, and visit free-roaming rescue hens on this 65-acre communal sanctuary and artist retreat.
- 📍 Near Fort Drum
- 💸 $$
- ⚡ Up for anything
- 🌗 Indoors
Where: 31060 Cottage Hill Road, Redwood, NY 13679
Hours: Added 2026-11-18 — confirm current hours before you go.
Pair it with
- Boldt Castle & Yacht House on Heart Island — A nine-mile jump that takes you from Better Farm's scrappy, solar-powered communalism directly to George Boldt's tragic, monumental Gilded Age stone palace on the river.
- Thousand Islands Winery & 1836 Stone Farm — Pair Redwood's alternative sustainability lab with cold-hardy estate wines poured inside an 1836 stone farmstead eleven miles west.
- Giant Roll of Lifesavers — Drive fourteen miles northeast toward Gouverneur to balance Better Farm's earnest green philosophy with pure, unabashed roadside candy pop-art.
More weird in Watertown & Fort Drum
Good to know
Can I just drop in and walk around the grounds?
No. Better Farm is an active intentional community, sanctuary, and residential workspace. Day visits must be coordinated in advance for scheduled tours or workshops, or timed to public gatherings like the annual Better Festival.
What animals are on the property?
Better Farm operates an animal sanctuary rather than a commercial petting zoo. Permanent residents typically include rescued laying hens, alpacas, and rehabilitated domestic animals.
What is Better Radio?
It is WAIB 88.5 LPFM, a low-power, commercial-free radio station broadcast directly from the farm by the on-site nonprofit betterArts. It streams local voices, independent music, talk shows, and North Country updates.
Can you stay overnight?
Yes. The farm rents out rooms inside the main 19th-century farmhouse and offers rustic tent and glamping sites around the property through platforms like Hipcamp and Airbnb.
Plan a visit & invite your people →
Further reading: hipcamp.com · motherearthnews.com · onegreenplanet.org · wwoofusa.org · Official site
last checked: 2026-11-18


