The Claire House — Haunted & Secret History in Watertown & Fort Drum
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 28 — the Watertown & Fort Drum file — filed under: miscellanea

The Claire House

Featured on Ghost Hunters, this historic bed and breakfast is plagued by mysterious flickering lights, strange noises, and things that go bump in the night, offering overnight ghost investigation packages.

→ Three more haunted places & dark-history spots in Watertown & Fort Drum — never the same twice

The story

In 1884, Ogdensburg erected a massive brick rectory on Franklin Street to house the priests serving St. Mary's Cathedral next door. Father Joseph H. Conroy—who later became Bishop of Ogdensburg—oversaw its construction and lived in the house for thirty-seven years. When a fire gutted the cathedral in 1947, priests pulled sacred relics from the burning sanctuary and stashed them in the rectory's subterranean vaults. By 1960, a modern cathedral opened elsewhere, and the old rectory was handed over to the Grey Nuns of the Order of the Sacred Heart. For the next forty-five years, the sisters ran the building as a convent and makeshift orphanage until departing in 2005, leaving a century of institutional prayers, childhood grief, and consecrated stone behind.

Current owners Hal and Rachel bought the neglected manse in 2019, stripping back decades of grime and renaming it The Claire House. During renovations, they unearthed an altar stone hidden in the basement containing the sealed bone relics of two Catholic saints—along with sealed doorways and unexplained drafts. By 2023, the paranormal series Ghost Hunters arrived with audio rigs and infrared cameras to document what the owners were experiencing: the rhythmic click-clack of hard leather soles pacing the halls (attributed to Bishop Conroy), a gaunt figure dubbed the 'skeleton-faced lady' rattling bedroom doorknobs, and the disembodied giggles of a child darting past the servants' staircase.

What it's like

A stay here feels less like a sanitized country inn and more like sleeping inside an active historical dig with things that move in the dark. Owners Hal and Rachel run the property themselves and are happy to point out active hot spots and show you the basement where church relics were cached for decades. Don't expect free rein for occult shenanigans: house rules strictly prohibit Ouija boards and conjuring rituals, and quiet hours kick in at 10 PM. If you book an overnight investigation package, pack your own audio recorder and EMF meter—the house turns dead silent after midnight, making the distinct sound of deliberate footsteps on empty upper floors impossible to explain away.

The move: Book an overnight ghost investigation package, explore the basement where burning cathedral relics were once cached, and ask owners Hal and Rachel to point out the building's most active paranormal hot spots.

Where: 709 Franklin Street, Ogdensburg, NY 13669

Hours: Added 2026-11-18 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Brouse House — Double down on North Country ghost lore by pairing your rectory stay with a visit to this Norfolk property, another regional magnet for paranormal investigators.
  • Singer Castle on Dark Island — Trade church spooks for Gilded Age paranoia twenty-three miles southwest at this 1905 granite river castle, complete with hidden passageways and peepholes inside the walls.
  • Boldt Castle & Yacht House on Heart Island — Continue down the St. Lawrence to see what happens when sudden death halts construction on a 120-room stone palace, leaving it abandoned for over seventy years.

More weird in Watertown & Fort Drum

Good to know

How do you book an overnight stay or paranormal investigation?

All stays and after-hours ghost investigation packages must be booked in advance through The Claire House's website or Airbnb; walk-ins are not accommodated.

Are Ouija boards or séances allowed?

No. The property enforces a strict rule banning Ouija boards, conjuring rituals, and amateur séances, though passive monitoring tools like EMF meters, spirit boxes, and cameras are permitted.

What was discovered in the basement during renovations?

The owners found an altar stone containing certified bone relics of two saints, which had been salvaged from the 1947 St. Mary's Cathedral fire and hidden in the rectory basement for decades.

Can you visit without booking an overnight room?

The owners periodically offer 45-to-60-minute daytime guided ghost tours and basement add-ons by advance reservation, though the full investigation packages require booking an overnight stay.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: newyorkupstate.com · hauntedhistorytrail.com · spectrumlocalnews.com · airbnb.com · Official site

last checked: 2026-11-18