Spiritual Lighthouse Church — Occult & Mystical in Jacksonville & Mayport
🗺️ See it on Google Maps — real photos & reviews →

Entry No. 22 — the Jacksonville & Mayport file — filed under: miscellanea

Spiritual Lighthouse Church

JaxPsychoGeo described it in 2021 as Jacksonville’s only remaining Spiritualist church and recounts a visitor’s first trip there in 1973.

→ Three at a time, never the same twice — explore weird Jacksonville & Mayport

The story

Jacksonville is rarely recognized as a sanctuary for mediums and channeled spirits—that reputation belongs almost entirely to Cassadaga a few hours south. Yet tucked away at 1049 Crestwood Street, shaded by old-growth oaks in a quiet Northside neighborhood, sits a compact, 1,275-square-foot white chapel that spent over half a century operating as the city’s lone institutional redoubt of modern Spiritualism. Archival periodicals from the International Association for the Preservation of Spiritualist and Occult Periodicals show the address listed in spiritual journals like Chimes as early as 1963 under Pastor Reverend Ida Pierce, offering Wednesday night message circles, Thursday Bible classes, and Sunday healing.

To the congregation, speaking with departed souls wasn't a spooky carnival trick or a Halloween stunt; it was an everyday article of religious faith. Tim Gilmore documented the church on JaxPsychoGeo in 2021, detailing how a visitor's initial 1973 trip uncovered an ordinary-looking room conducting business utterly alien to the surrounding Bible Belt orthodoxy. Over the decades, leadership passed to devoted ministers like Reverend Marilynn Beasley—an Air Force wife who was ordained in 1986 and led the congregation from 1999 until her death in 2011—and visiting teachers like Reverend Stanley Kotce. Inside, beneath an acoustic baby grand piano and beneath rows of modest pews that seated about sixty people, congregants received spirit readings and attended monthly second-Saturday psychic fairs.

The property's long Spiritualist chapter shifted in late 2022 when the building was sold and transferred to another local ministry, while the original corporation entered an inactive state. What remains on Crestwood is the quiet, unassuming shell: a physical monument to sixty years of documented séances and clairvoyance conducted in plain daylight inside a standard suburban church.

What it's like

A drive down Crestwood Street delivers you into a sleepy residential pocket where the modest white sanctuary looks indistinguishable from any other small neighborhood chapel. There are no crystal balls, velvet curtains, or supernatural markers visible from the road—just a neat, small-scale building on shaded lots. Because the property was sold in late 2022 and regular Spiritualist events on-site are no longer active, treat this as a respectful exterior pilgrimage rather than a venue for walk-in psychic readings. Pull curbside for a quiet look at the suburban facade where generations of Jacksonville mediums practiced their craft.

The move: Take a slow drive down Crestwood Street, spot the little white chapel under the old oaks, and take turns guessing what a Wednesday night message circle sounded like.

Where: 1049 Crestwood St, Jacksonville, FL 32208

Hours: Added 2026-11-17 — confirm current hours before you go.

Pair it with

  • Old City Cemetery of Jacksonville — Pair Jacksonville's long-running outpost of spirit communion with the 1852 cemetery where Victorian crypts and yellow fever victims rest beneath mossy oaks.
  • Durkeeville History Museum — Head less than two miles south to explore the deep twentieth-century civic and cultural history of one of Jacksonville's primary historic Black neighborhoods.
  • El Modelo Block — Continue downtown to examine a cigar factory that survived the 1901 Great Fire and carries its own century-old haunting lore.
  • The Volstead — Debrief your tour of Jacksonville’s esoteric fringe over classic cocktails hidden behind heavy velvet curtains on Adams Street.

More weird in Jacksonville & Mayport

Good to know

Is Spiritual Lighthouse Church still holding psychic fairs and message services?

Not at this location. Property records show the chapel was sold in late 2022 to a different ministry, and the original Spiritualist corporate entity went into inactive status, bringing its decades of regular on-site psychic fairs and Sunday circles to an end.

What happened during a typical service here?

Services combined conventional worship elements—hymns, prayer, and lectures—with core Spiritualist practices, including hands-on healing and regular 'message circles' where ordained mediums relayed guidance and messages from spirits to attendees.

How old is the church?

While the church incorporated as a Florida non-profit in December 1980, documented listings in national Spiritualist directories place services and message circles at 1049 Crestwood as far back as 1963.

Can you tour the interior?

No. The building is private property situated in a residential neighborhood. Visits are strictly drive-by or curbside exterior viewing.

Plan a visit & invite your people →

Further reading: jaxpsychogeo.com · yellowpages.com · Official site · bizstanding.com · iapsop.com · crexi.com

last checked: 2026-11-17